Most goals off bench in Premier League history: Jhon Duran chasing substitute record for single season

By | December 10, 2024

Jhon Duran’s start to the 2024/25 season has brought consistent joy to Aston Villa fans, finding a key role as a super sub and winning the club significant points late in matches.

The 20-year-old Colombia forward joined in the summer of 2023 from MLS side Chicago Fire and has settled into his Premier League home quite well.

Coming off the bench in each of Aston Villa’s first nine Premier League matches of the season, Duran has scored four goals, with three of them proving to be match-winning strikes.

While the young Villa striker could be on his way towards a single-season record, Duran has quite a ways to go before he can be considered one of the league’s most prolific substitute goal scorers. The Sporting News brings you all the info on who Duran is chasing and how far he has to go.

MORE: Updated Premier League top goal scorers list for 2024/25 season

Most goals by a substitute in Premier League history

The most goals by a substitute across an entire Premier League career came from Jermain Defoe, whose 24 super-sub strikes are three more than anyone else.

Arsenal and Chelsea striker Olivier Giroud comes next, as roughly 40% of his Premier League appearances came off the bench and he became adept at contributing in such a role.

Stats up to date as of October 31, 2024.

Player Substitute Goals Overall goals Apps (Subs) Clubs
Jermain Defoe 24 162 496 (149) Tottenham, Sunderland, West Ham, Portsmouth, Bournemouth
Olivier Giroud 21 90 255 (103) Arsenal, Chelsea
Javier Hernandez 19 53 158 (78) Man United, West Ham
Nwankwo Kanu 17 54 271 (116) Arsenal, Portsmouth, West Brom
Daniel Sturridge 17 76 218 (98) Liverpool, Chelsea, Man City, Bolton, West Brom
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer 17 91 235 (84) Man United
Peter Crouch 16 108 468 (157) Stoke City, Liverpool, Tottenham, Portsmouth, Aston Villa, Southampton, Burnley
Danny Welbeck* 15 73 342 (131) Brighton, Man United, Arsenal, Sunderland, Watford

* Active currently for Premier League club

Most goals by a substitute in a single Premier League season

The most substitute goals in a single campaign by a Premier League player was eight by Adam Le Fondre of Reading in the 2012/13 season.

It’s two more than anyone else, as three players struck six times off the bench on four separate occasions.

Jhon Duran had four goals as substitute in 2024/25 only two months into the Premier League campaign, well on his way to the record. However, he could fall short if he becomes a regular in the Aston Villa starting lineup, cutting down his opportunities to come off the bench and make an impact.

Brighton’s Danny Welbeck is the active leader in goals as a Premier League substitute with 15, with over half coming for his current club. Marcus Rashford has the most match-winning substitute goals in league history with five, a number that Duran is already over halfway to with three this season alone.

Player Club Season Substitute goals Overall goals Apps (Sub)
Adam Le Fondre Reading 2012/13 8 12 34 (23)
Olivier Giroud Arsenal/Chelsea 2017/18 6 7 29 (22)
Olivier Giroud Arsenal 2016/17 6 12 29 (18)
Jermain Defoe West Ham 2001/02 6 10 35 (21)
Christian Benteke Liverpool 2015/16 6 9 29 (15)

Jhon Duran as a super-sub for Aston Villa this season

The 2024/25 season has marked a breakout year for Jhon Duran, who has been prolific off the bench for Unai Emery.

Duran exploded to life at the start of the season, scoring in four of the first five Premier League matches, all off the bench. He chipped in another two in Champions League play through October, one as a starter and the other off the bench.

It would take him two months to find the net again, doing so as a starter in Premier League action against Southampton before bagging a critical goal against RB Leipzig after being brought on at halftime.

Jhon Duran substitute goals in 2024/25 season

Date Opponent Competition Goals
Aug. 17, 2024 West Ham Premier League 1
Aug. 31, 2024 Leicester City Premier League 1
Sep. 14, 2024 Everton Premier League 1
Sep. 21, 2024 Wolves Premier League 1
Oct. 2, 2024 Bayern Munich Champions League 1
Dec. 10, 2024 RB Leipzig Champions League 1
TOTAL     6

Source