Tyler Herro is on the verge of returning for the Heat, and that presents some interesting questions for the team.
Herro broke two fingers on his shooting hand in the first game of the Heat’s first round series against the Bucks, but he has been a full participant in the team’s practices and is expected to return for Game 3 on Wednesday, per TNT’s Jared Greenberg. Herro was one of the most important players on the Heat during the regular season, but they’ve been playing well in his absence. How can they incorporate him back into the team without losing the chemistry that they’ve built throughout their postseason run?
How the Heat overcame the loss of Herro
Herro led the team in minutes during the regular season and was slated to ramp up even more in the playoffs. Only Jimmy Butler logged more time than Herro’s 39 minutes in their play-in win against the Bulls, his last full game.
Since then, the Heat have essentially redistributed Herro’s minutes to Gabe Vincent, Caleb Martin, and Duncan Robinson.
| Player |
Minutes in second play-in game |
Minutes in Game 6 vs. Celtics |
|---|---|---|
| Vincent | 27 | 41 |
| Martin | 27 | 40 |
| Robinson | 0 | 20 |
Vincent and Martin’s play have been outstanding. Both have brought tough defense and great shot-making, hitting 41 and 44 percent of their 3’s in the playoffs respectively. But it has been Robinson’s re-emergence that has come totally out of the blue.
MORE: Nikola Jokic or Jimmy Butler? Ranking 10 best players in the Finals
Duncan Robinson has been a revelation in his return to the rotation
Robinson had an up-and-mostly-down season for the Heat. He was completely out of the rotation for much of the second half of the season and didn’t play at all in the Heat’s play-in games. Had Herro not gotten hurt, there’s a good chance that Robinson would have continued to be a healthy scratch throughout the playoffs.
Robinson is obviously a supremely talented shooter, hitting 39.9 percent of his 3’s for his career. But that number had fallen off to just 32.8 percent during the regular season. Mired in a deep shooting slump, it was tough to play him because of how big of a liability he also is on defense.
It’s safe to say that Robinson has busted out of that slump in a big way. He’s hit a scorching 44.0 percent of his 3’s in the playoffs. His 10 points in the fourth quarter of Game 2 was the difference-maker in their Game 2 win. And the Heat have been able to live with him on defense by hiding him in the back of their 2-3 zone, where he’s less likely to get called over and over into pick-and-rolls.
MORE: Three reasons why the Heat will win the 2023 NBA Finals
What do the Heat do with Duncan Robinson when Tyler Herro comes back?
Robinson and Herro do have some overlap both in their strengths (scoring) and weaknesses (defense). Can the Heat get away with playing both together? They tried it for 200 minutes during the regular season, including briefly against the Nuggets during the regular season.
Those minutes went pretty much exactly as you’d expect — per PBP Stats, the team had a scorching 118.8 offensive rating but an even worse 119.3 defensive rating.
That same phenomenon happened against the Nuggets. They were able to score well, and the Heat tried mixing in some zone to hide both of them. But they were both targeted on defense, and they were outscored in those minutes. For the most part, Erik Spoelstra has tried to stagger their minutes so only one of them is on the floor at a time.
If the series starts off well for the Heat, then it’s plausible that they will keep Herro’s minutes down and keep on riding with Robinson. If they struggle out of the gate, then maybe they ramp Herro up quickly out of desperation.
Ultimately though, the Heat’s best chance at winning might be to live with the defensive warts and have both of them on the floor as much as possible. They have no good options to defend Nikola Jokic anyway, so they may have to try and keep up with the Nuggets’ offensive firepower in order to steal some wins.
MORE: Heat vs. Nuggets prediction: Which team will win NBA Finals?
What Tyler Herro can add in his return to the lineup
It’s important to note that the Heat haven’t gotten better because of the absence of Herro. Rather, they’ve improved because everyone on the team has stepped up their play.
Herro was helping the Heat when he was healthy. He can still bring a ton of value upon his return. They badly need some playmaking to give Butler some breathers, who has taken on a heavy load throughout multiple grueling playoff series and two play-in games.
Herro gives them on-ball creation. He played well against this Nuggets defense during the regular season, dropping 26 points, 10 rebounds, and five assists and running the offense for large stretches. He has gotten better as a passer, although he is turnover-prone when double-teamed. And the Nuggets struggled to contain his shooting off movement and pull-up jumpers.
Herro’s return gives the Heat some issues to work through, but it’s a good problem to have. They are going to need all the help that they can get to pull off the upset, and Herro will give them a puncher’s chance.